Amsterdam Inn
With cathedral-high ceilings, suits of armour lining the hallways, artwork on every wall, and a jaw-dropping entrance hall housed within a historic former armory, this eccentric, spotlessly kept castle hotel delivers a theatrical sense of occasion that goes well beyond a mere place to sleep.
How the cosy score works →Why it scores 7.0, from guest reviews
- Suits of armour lining hallways, castle atmosphere with thoughtful period details and artwork throughout
- Friendly, kind personal service from staff; unexpected room upgrades and late-night assistance
- Historic character woven into the building itself—guests felt they'd stepped into a castle, with Kennedy campaign room adding narrative warmth
Best for
A strong fit for history and character, design lovers and a treat. Guests point to former armory building with suits of armour lining hallways, period details, artwork throughout, and historic credentials including a and ostentatiously decorated with cathedral-high ceilings, artwork on every wall, thoughtful details, and eclectic architectural elements.
Booking via this link may earn us a commission; it never affects cosy scores.
More cosy hotels in New York
See the New York guide →- 7.0The Greenwich Hotel
- 7.0The Inn at Irving Place
- 6.9The Sherry-Netherland
- 6.7Untitled at 3 Freeman Alley
- 6.6Crosby Street Hotel
- 6.5The Wallace
Explore cosy hotels in New York by style
Frequently asked questions
- Where is Amsterdam Inn located?
- Amsterdam Inn is in New York, United States, and guests praise its central location as close to everything in the city.
- How cosy is Amsterdam Inn?
- Amsterdam Inn has a cosy score of 7.0 out of 10, making it a unique, character-filled stay rather than a traditionally intimate retreat.
- What is the décor like at Amsterdam Inn?
- Amsterdam Inn is a historic former armory transformed into a castle-themed hotel with suits of armour lining the hallways, cathedral-like ceilings, and artwork on every wall, guests describe it as breathtaking and magical.
- Are the rooms at Amsterdam Inn clean and well-maintained?
- Yes, guests consistently praise the rooms as spotless and immaculate, with spacious layouts that feel unique and historic.
- Is the service good at Amsterdam Inn?
- Staff receive warm praise from guests for being friendly, helpful, and kind, with particular mention of attentive late-night check-ins.
- Is Amsterdam Inn good value for money?
- Guests describe it as reasonably priced for a first-rate, historic hotel with impressive architecture and décor, making it excellent value for a one-of-a-kind experience.
Show off your AI cosy score: paste this on your site and it links back to your ranking.