Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel
Beautifully decorated rooms, a made-to-order breakfast of daily-changing specials, including those much-praised lemon ricotta pancakes, and warmly attentive hosts Paul and Emily place this quietly situated, walkable island inn a cut above the ordinary, though a recurring air-conditioning issue on the upper floor and the owner's reluctance to offer even a small gesture of goodwill when it failed suggest the hospitality, for all its charm, can occasionally fall short of the premium it commands.
How the cosy score works →Why it scores 6.9, from guest reviews
- Named, attentive innkeepers (Paul, Emily, Joey, Bill) who remember returning guests and offer personalised service including turndown and made-to-order breakfasts
- Quiet, intimate setting with covered balconies, gardens, gazebo, and deliberate distance from party crowds despite walkable downtown access
- Thoughtfully decorated rooms with high-quality furnishings, beautiful design, and small luxuries (robes, quality coffee, bicycles), plus excellent noise insulation
Best for
A strong fit for boutique character, peace and quiet and walking everywhere. Guests point to named, attentive innkeepers Paul and Emily run this small, owner-operated hotel with personalised service and thoughtful touches that.
Booking via this link may earn us a commission; it never affects cosy scores.
Frequently asked questions
- Where is Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel located?
- Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel is in Put-In-Bay on the island, positioned just off the downtown area but within easy walking distance of shops and restaurants.
- How cosy is Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel?
- Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel has a cosy score of 6.9 out of 10, with beautifully decorated rooms that guests consistently describe as spotless and welcoming.
- What is the breakfast like at Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel?
- Breakfast at Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel is made to order each morning by the owner Paul, with guests raving about dishes like lemon ricotta pancakes and praising it as delicious and fresh.
- Is the service good at Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel?
- Yes, guests consistently praise the staff as friendly, accommodating, and helpful, with particular mention of owners Paul and Emily going above and beyond to make stays special.
- What do guests think of Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel overall?
- Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel has a 4.8 out of 5 rating from 118 reviews, with guests calling it a gem, gorgeous, and their only choice for staying on Put-In-Bay.
Show off your AI cosy score: paste this on your site and it links back to your ranking.