Carlton Arms Hotel
New York, United States
6.0COSY
Wildly eccentric rather than polished, the Carlton Arms charms with its room-by-room artwork covering every surface, a resident cat named Ned roaming the corridors, friendly and attentive staff, and a brilliantly central Manhattan location, though travellers should arrive prepared for narrow staircases, no lift, and decidedly no-frills amenities.
How the cosy score works →Why it scores 6.0, from guest reviews
- Eclectic artwork throughout creating character and personality
- Resident cat (Ned) adding warmth and lived-in charm
- Friendly, responsive staff who remember repeat guests
- Old building with narrow stairwell suggesting intimate, small-scale feel
Best for
A strong fit for design lovers, boutique character and walking everywhere. Guests point to the hotel features room-by-room artwork covering every surface, creating an eclectic and visually distinctive interior that guests.
Booking via this link may earn us a commission; it never affects cosy scores.
More cosy hotels in New York
See the New York guide →- 7.0The Inn at Irving Place
- 7.0The Greenwich Hotel
- 7.0Amsterdam Inn
- 6.9The Sherry-Netherland
- 6.7Untitled at 3 Freeman Alley
- 6.6Crosby Street Hotel
Explore cosy hotels in New York by style
Frequently asked questions
- Where is Carlton Arms Hotel located?
- Carlton Arms Hotel is in New York, with excellent transport links, subway stations and buses are just a short walk away, making it ideal for exploring the city.
- How cosy is Carlton Arms Hotel?
- Carlton Arms Hotel has a cosy score of 6.0 out of 10. It's a no-frills, eclectic place with character rather than comfort, guests appreciate its quirky charm and artistic vibe over luxury amenities.
- What's special about the rooms at Carlton Arms Hotel?
- Every room at Carlton Arms Hotel is covered in beautiful, original artwork, making the entire hotel feel like an art exhibit. Guests consistently praise the creative, interesting décor and cleanliness.
- Is the staff friendly at Carlton Arms Hotel?
- Yes, staff at Carlton Arms Hotel are consistently described as friendly, kind and responsive to guest requests. They're known for going the extra mile with things like providing darker curtains or extra hangers.
- What should I know about staying at Carlton Arms Hotel?
- Carlton Arms Hotel is housed in an old building with three flights of stairs and no lift, so climbing with luggage can be a bit awkward, but guests who stay find it worth it for the location, artwork and welcoming atmosphere. The hotel even has a resident cat.
Own this hotel? Add your cosy badge
Show off your AI cosy score: paste this on your site and it links back to your ranking.